Welt Hok
  • Investing
  • Latest News
  • Editor’s Pick
  • Economy
  • Investing
  • Latest News
  • Editor’s Pick
  • Economy
No Result
View All Result
Welt Hok
No Result
View All Result
Home Investing

The minoritarian power imbalance that gave Trump immunity

by
July 2, 2024
in Investing
0
The minoritarian power imbalance that gave Trump immunity

Last month, YouGov conducted a poll for CBS News that included a question focused specifically on the Supreme Court case for which a decision came down Monday. Should American presidents, the pollsters asked, be granted broad immunity from criminal prosecution for actions they took in service of their presidencies?

Most Americans — more than two-thirds, in fact — said no. There were differences by political affiliation, with Democrats overwhelmingly rejecting the idea that a president should have such power. Among Republicans, a majority disagreed with offering that sort of protection, but only a relatively narrow one.

That’s not entirely surprising, given the genesis for the question. Donald Trump, indicted on state and federal charges for attempting to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election, had argued that he (and every president) had a tacit protection from prosecution for engaging in those actions. Republicans were more likely than Democrats to support this sort of immunity, we can assume, because some portion of them recognized that it was Trump that we were really talking about.

But we don’t need to guess here. YouGov asked half of respondents specifically whether Trump should have that sort of immunity. Again, most respondents said he shouldn’t. This time, though, most Republicans — about two-thirds — said he should.

On Monday, that Republican minority got its wish — largely because of the systematic advantages Republicans have enjoyed in the Senate and thanks to the electoral college.

There are nine members of the court. The longest-serving member is Justice Clarence Thomas, nominated by George H.W. Bush and confirmed in 1991. The newest member is Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, nominated by President Biden and confirmed in 2022.

But there’s a difference between the confirmations of those two justices. Thomas’s deeply controversial nomination earned him 52 Senate votes. Jackson’s far-less-controversial nomination landed in the modern era, when bipartisan approval of Supreme Court nominations has been abandoned. She got 53 votes.

Because of the way that power is allocated in the Senate, though, Jackson got support from senators representing far more of the country than Thomas did. Rural, lightly populated states get the same two senators that more-urban, densely populated ones do, meaning that — to use the standard example — California’s 39 million residents get the same number of senators as Wyoming’s 580,000.

If we allocate half of their state’s population to each senator, Thomas got the support of senators representing just under half the population. Jackson got the support of senators representing 57 percent of the population.

Using that same calculus, three other sitting justices also got support from senators representing less than half of the country: Justices Neil M. Gorsuch, Brett M. Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett, all of whom were appointed by Trump.

Trump, of course, won the presidency thanks to another power structure that has often benefited Republicans: the electoral college. He lost the popular vote in 2016 but became president anyway, earning the right to fill a vacancy on the court immediately and then two more over the course of his presidency.

That he had the right to fill that vacancy immediately, of course, is itself a function of the imbalance of power in the Senate. Then-Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) rejected President Barack Obama’s 2016 nominee, Merrick Garland, something he was able to do given the Republican majority in the chamber. That majority represented about 47 percent of the country’s population. (When another court vacancy emerged in 2020, McConnell used his party’s majority to fill it immediately.)

Two other justices, Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justice Samuel Alito, benefited from these advantages in another way. Alito was confirmed by senators representing barely more than half the country’s population, despite receiving 58 votes in the Senate. But he, like Roberts, was nominated by George W. Bush, who had been first elected in 2000 thanks to the electoral college. He was reelected in 2004 with a popular vote majority — the first Republican to do so since his father’s election in 1988. But had the popular vote determined the winner in 2000, it’s not clear any Republican would have been elected four years later.

As defenders of Trump and the Supreme Court will immediately note: This is how the system works. And that is true. It is. Five members of the nine-person Supreme Court can be nominated by presidents who lost the popular vote when they first ran, and four of them can be confirmed by senators representing less than half the country. Then they can decide, against the views of two-thirds of the country, that a president who lost the popular vote should have immunity from criminal charges for having attempted to subvert the results after he lost the popular vote again.

It’s how the system works.

This post appeared first on The Washington Post
Previous Post

Biden team courts skittish Democrats as path to replace him narrows

Next Post

Impact of European Political Climate on The Global Market

Next Post
Impact of European Political Climate on The Global Market

Impact of European Political Climate on The Global Market

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Trade Surplus: Key Insights and Impacts on Currency

Trade Surplus: Key Insights and Impacts on Currency

August 30, 2024
Mike Johnson re-elected House speaker as GOP mutiny threat dissolves

Mike Johnson re-elected House speaker as GOP mutiny threat dissolves

January 3, 2025
House Republicans introduce bill to repurchase Panama Canal after Trump raises concerns of Chinese control

House Republicans introduce bill to repurchase Panama Canal after Trump raises concerns of Chinese control

January 9, 2025
Who is Giorgia Meloni? Trump hosts Italian PM at Mar-a-Lago

Who is Giorgia Meloni? Trump hosts Italian PM at Mar-a-Lago

January 5, 2025
Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law

Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law

0
Candidate who filmed himself in the Capitol on Jan. 6 seeks House seat

Candidate who filmed himself in the Capitol on Jan. 6 seeks House seat

0
Biden nearly died of an aneurysm. Risky surgery changed his life.

Biden nearly died of an aneurysm. Risky surgery changed his life.

0
Stellar and Bitcoin Cash: Stellar still in a bearish trend

Stellar and Bitcoin Cash: Stellar still in a bearish trend

0
Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law

Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law

July 9, 2025
Biden’s strange use of teleprompter in donor’s home infuriated supporters, dashed expectations

Biden’s strange use of teleprompter in donor’s home infuriated supporters, dashed expectations

July 9, 2025
Waymo offers teen accounts for driverless rides

Waymo offers teen accounts for driverless rides

July 8, 2025
Supreme Court lets Trump’s ‘wrecking ball’ federal job cuts proceed while legal fight continues

Supreme Court lets Trump’s ‘wrecking ball’ federal job cuts proceed while legal fight continues

July 8, 2025
Enter Your Information Below To Receive Trading Ideas and Latest News

    Become a VIP member by signing up for our newsletter. Enjoy exclusive content, early access to sales, and special offers just for you! As a VIP, you'll receive personalized updates, loyalty rewards, and invitations to private events. Elevate your experience and join our exclusive community today!


    By opting in you agree to receive emails from us and our affiliates. Your information is secure and your privacy is protected.

    Your information is secure and your privacy is protected. By opting in you agree to receive emails from us. Remember that you can opt-out any time, we hate spam too!
    • Trending
    • Comments
    • Latest
    Trade Surplus: Key Insights and Impacts on Currency

    Trade Surplus: Key Insights and Impacts on Currency

    August 30, 2024
    Mike Johnson re-elected House speaker as GOP mutiny threat dissolves

    Mike Johnson re-elected House speaker as GOP mutiny threat dissolves

    January 3, 2025
    House Republicans introduce bill to repurchase Panama Canal after Trump raises concerns of Chinese control

    House Republicans introduce bill to repurchase Panama Canal after Trump raises concerns of Chinese control

    January 9, 2025
    Who is Giorgia Meloni? Trump hosts Italian PM at Mar-a-Lago

    Who is Giorgia Meloni? Trump hosts Italian PM at Mar-a-Lago

    January 5, 2025
    Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law

    Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law

    0
    Candidate who filmed himself in the Capitol on Jan. 6 seeks House seat

    Candidate who filmed himself in the Capitol on Jan. 6 seeks House seat

    0
    Biden nearly died of an aneurysm. Risky surgery changed his life.

    Biden nearly died of an aneurysm. Risky surgery changed his life.

    0
    Stellar and Bitcoin Cash: Stellar still in a bearish trend

    Stellar and Bitcoin Cash: Stellar still in a bearish trend

    0
    Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law

    Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law

    July 9, 2025
    Biden’s strange use of teleprompter in donor’s home infuriated supporters, dashed expectations

    Biden’s strange use of teleprompter in donor’s home infuriated supporters, dashed expectations

    July 9, 2025
    Waymo offers teen accounts for driverless rides

    Waymo offers teen accounts for driverless rides

    July 8, 2025
    Supreme Court lets Trump’s ‘wrecking ball’ federal job cuts proceed while legal fight continues

    Supreme Court lets Trump’s ‘wrecking ball’ federal job cuts proceed while legal fight continues

    July 8, 2025

    Top News

    Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law

    Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law

    July 9, 2025
    Biden’s strange use of teleprompter in donor’s home infuriated supporters, dashed expectations

    Biden’s strange use of teleprompter in donor’s home infuriated supporters, dashed expectations

    July 9, 2025

    Latest News

    • Tariff case pits Cato Institute against Trump over ‘unlimited’ executive power under emergency law
    • Biden’s strange use of teleprompter in donor’s home infuriated supporters, dashed expectations
    • Waymo offers teen accounts for driverless rides

    About Welthok

    • About us
    • Contacts
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
    • About us
    • Contacts
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Copyright © 2025 welthok.com | All Rights Reserved

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Investing
    • Latest News
    • Editor’s Pick
    • Economy

    Copyright © 2025 welthok.com | All Rights Reserved